Difference between revisions of "Adaptive Security 2020F: Paper Review Instructions"

From Soma-notes
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with "When you are reviewing a paper for this class to assess how it relates to adaptive security, please use the following template. * '''Title:''' * '''Authors:''' * '''Published...")
 
Line 5: Line 5:
* '''Published in:''' Specify the paper's publishing venue (conference, journal) and how to find it there (year or volume & issue)
* '''Published in:''' Specify the paper's publishing venue (conference, journal) and how to find it there (year or volume & issue)
* '''Link to paper:'''
* '''Link to paper:'''
* '''Reviewed by:''' your name
* '''Date Reviewed:''' when you wrote this up
* '''Problem:''' Briefly explain the problem the paper addresses
* '''Problem:''' Briefly explain the problem the paper addresses
* '''What they did''': Briefly explain what they did to address their problem, whether it was to develop an attack, build a defense, make a theory, did a user study, or something else.
* '''What they did''': Briefly explain what they did to address their problem, whether it was to develop an attack, build a defense, make a theory, did a user study, or something else.

Revision as of 10:00, 8 October 2020

When you are reviewing a paper for this class to assess how it relates to adaptive security, please use the following template.

  • Title:
  • Authors:
  • Published in: Specify the paper's publishing venue (conference, journal) and how to find it there (year or volume & issue)
  • Link to paper:
  • Reviewed by: your name
  • Date Reviewed: when you wrote this up
  • Problem: Briefly explain the problem the paper addresses
  • What they did: Briefly explain what they did to address their problem, whether it was to develop an attack, build a defense, make a theory, did a user study, or something else.
  • Adaptive? Give a score from -2 to 2 as follows:
    • -2: Helps attackers and defenders cannot respond easily
    • -1: Helps attackers but defenders can respond easily
    • 0: Neither helps attackers or defenders
    • 1: Helps defenders but attackers can respond easily
    • 2: Helps defenders and attackers cannot respond easily
  • Rationale: Explain the rationale for your adaptive score