Adaptive Security 2020F: Paper Review Instructions: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 19:00, 8 October 2020

When you are reviewing a paper for this class to assess how it relates to adaptive security, please use the following template.

Paper Details

Title:

Authors:

Published in: Specify the paper's publishing venue (conference, journal) and how to find it there (year or volume & issue)

Link to paper:

Reviewed by: your name

Date Reviewed: when you wrote this up

Problem

Briefly explain the problem the paper addresses

Contribution

Briefly explain what they did to address their problem, whether it was to develop an attack, build a defense, make a theory, did a user study, or something else.

Adaptive Analysis

Adaptive Score: Give a score from -2 to 2 as follows:

-2: Helps attackers and defenders cannot respond easily
-1: Helps attackers but defenders can respond easily
0: Neither helps attackers or defenders
1: Helps defenders but attackers can respond easily
2: Helps defenders and attackers cannot respond easily

Rationale: Explain the rationale for your adaptive score

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 When you are reviewing a paper for this class to assess how it relates to adaptive security, please use the following template.
-* '''Title:'''
+==Paper Details==
-* '''Authors:'''
+'''Title:'''
-* '''Published in:''' Specify the paper's publishing venue (conference, journal) and how to find it there (year or volume & issue)
-* '''Link to paper:'''
+'''Authors:'''
-* '''Reviewed by:''' your name
-* '''Date Reviewed:''' when you wrote this up
+'''Published in:''' Specify the paper's publishing venue (conference, journal) and how to find it there (year or volume & issue)
-* '''Problem:''' Briefly explain the problem the paper addresses
-* '''What they did''': Briefly explain what they did to address their problem, whether it was to develop an attack, build a defense, make a theory, did a user study, or something else.
+'''Link to paper:'''
-* '''Adaptive?''' Give a score from -2 to 2 as follows:
-** -2: Helps attackers and defenders cannot respond easily
+'''Reviewed by:''' your name
-** -1: Helps attackers but defenders can respond easily
-**  0: Neither helps attackers or defenders
+'''Date Reviewed:''' when you wrote this up
-**  1: Helps defenders but attackers can respond easily
-**  2: Helps defenders and attackers cannot respond easily
+==Problem==
-* '''Rationale:''' Explain the rationale for your adaptive score
+Briefly explain the problem the paper addresses
+==Contribution==
+Briefly explain what they did to address their problem, whether it was to develop an attack, build a defense, make a theory, did a user study, or something else.
+==Adaptive Analysis==
+'''Adaptive Score:''' Give a score from -2 to 2 as follows:
+* -2: Helps attackers and defenders cannot respond easily
+* -1: Helps attackers but defenders can respond easily
+*  0: Neither helps attackers or defenders
+*  1: Helps defenders but attackers can respond easily
+*  2: Helps defenders and attackers cannot respond easily
+'''Rationale:''' Explain the rationale for your adaptive score